Request a briefing

Essay · Strategy Design

The Gantt Chart Problem: Sensemaking in Organizations Before You Change Them

Why the method a team reaches for first already contains a judgment about its situation.

The Gantt Chart Problem is an essay on sensemaking in organizations for executive and leadership teams about to plan a change. It shows how the tools a team reaches for contain assumptions about its situation, and how to make sense of that situation before choosing a method.

Sensemaking in organizations is how a leadership team works out what is going on, and what to do about it, by joining each member’s observations into an account the team can act on. Sensemaking has to come before the change plan, because a planning method already contains a view of how predictable the coming work will be. A team that picks its method first has decided what kind of situation it faces before anyone discusses it. In our experience, many stalled changes trace back in part to that undiscussed decision.

A plan can turn a promising experiment into a premature commitment

Early results invite a rollout plan, as I saw at a large company running small experiments on team structure. Once a couple of teams were working well, I partnered with the change management lead. She opened Microsoft Project and began building a Gantt chart, a timeline of task bars.

I laughed and asked what she was doing. “Well, we’re going to build the project plan for scaling this out across the whole organization.”

“That destroys the experiments we’ve been doing,” I said, “because a Gantt chart assumes predictability and a linear causal relationship between things. That’s what Gantt charts are for. We are running experiments assuming complexity, and the Gantt chart assumes we are operating in an ordered context.”

You can’t Gantt chart your way to enterprise agility, and yet, when something looks like a project, our first thought is to enlist the enterprise project management office (EPMO). My concern was the commitment the chart would record: a rollout of a few early successes, on fixed dates, before the experiments had shown what to copy. The same chart serves the experiments when it schedules the next one and its review.

In our view, planning change on a Gantt chart has hardened into orthodoxy. The chart dates from the 1910s, when Henry Gantt designed it to compare what a shop had promised with what it produced and to record why each idle machine stood still, first in factories and then in wartime munitions production. A 1922 book helped spread its use. Project managers in a survey published in 2002 named Gantt charts and project software their most widely used aids. The chart fits work whose steps, order and durations are known in advance, such as a system upgrade.

Ordered and unordered situations call for different kinds of action

Before choosing a method, ask whether cause and effect can be known in advance. The answer splits the four kinds of situation in the Cynefin framework into two pairs. In a simple situation, cause and effect are obvious: boiling an egg follows a process anyone can repeat. In a complicated situation, finding them takes expertise. When your car breaks down, a mechanic can trace the fault to the alternator. Both kinds are ordered, and established practice, expert analysis and plans work in them.

Complex and chaotic situations are unordered. In a complex situation, cause and effect become visible only in hindsight, partly because each action changes the system it acts on. There, leaders set boundaries, teams run small experiments, and leaders invest in what shows promise and stop what does not. In a chaotic situation, a leader first acts to stabilize things. A team that cannot tell which of the four it faces is in a fifth condition, disorder.

A common failure, in our experience, is treating a complex situation as a complicated one. The challenges organizations face have few silver bullets and fewer best practices, and a humble leader still has options that point the way. One change effort often mixes several kinds. A plan still has a job there: it schedules the work already understood, such as a data migration, while the team runs experiments on the rest, such as who decides what.

A single frame shows a leadership team only part of what acts on it

A leadership team usually works from a habitual frame, which steers what its members notice. Many teams we work with default to the engineering frame, which treats the organization as a machine of roles, processes and reporting lines. Three other frames bring different forces into view. A people frame shows what people need from their work, what they can do and how they get along. Seen through a power frame, the organization is a jungle where groups compete for scarce resources. A meaning frame treats it as a theater and shows the stories people tell about their work and the purpose those stories serve.

One change looks different in each frame. A new reporting line alters coordination, working relationships, control of budgets and the meaning of each role.

A competitor, a regulator or a quiet change in customer habits can sit outside a team’s frames, and none of them waits to be noticed.

Sensemaking in organizations alternates between action and conversation

Sensemaking runs in a loop that never finishes. A team acts, notices what its action stirred up and talks about what that means, and the talk guides its next action.

A team can open the conversation with questions. What stories do people tell about our organization, and do they identify with our brand? What outside forces act on us, and how do we know? What have customers or colleagues noticed that our account leaves out? A leadership team’s situational awareness grows from discussing the answers and repeating the discussion while the team can still change its commitments, because each person hears what colleagues in other frames see.

A change in how people see their situation makes new practices possible

In my advisory work I aim at perception, and in my experience people then begin to change their own practices. A client I had advised for two years told me, “I see where you’re going with this. You’re trying to change the underlying mindsets, and that takes time.” The new practices outlast my advice where authority, funding and measures support them.

A room full of capable leaders can still miss the assumptions inside their tools. At a strategy design breakfast in Australia, a senior leader asked me, “Will, if we understand that everything is changing fast, and we need to be adaptable, why is it so hard? We’re in a room filled with smart and successful people, so why do so many transformations fail, and why do so many strategies fail?”

I answered with a question: “If the world is unordered, that is, complex and volatile, why do we continue to apply best practices based on a mindset and management assumptions that arose over a century ago in a manufacturing context?”

Our answer to that morning’s questions begins with sorting the work into what can be planned, what needs expert analysis and what has to be learned through experiments, and then letting those trials change the plan. A plan that requires the same rollout regardless of what the team learns has already closed the inquiry.


The talk Why Transformations Stall shows how management methods lose their context as they spread from one organization to the next. Request a briefing.

Questions leaders ask about sensemaking in organizations

What is sensemaking in organizations?

Sensemaking in organizations is how leaders work out what is going on and what to do about it, by joining their separate observations into an account they can act on. The work never finishes. Leaders act, compare what each of them sees from a different frame, and revise their account when events turn out differently than it predicted.

When is a Gantt chart the wrong tool for organizational change?

A Gantt chart is the wrong tool when its dates commit the whole organization to a rollout before small experiments have shown what works. The chart assumes the steps, order and durations of the work are known in advance, as they are in a system upgrade. Organizational change is often complex: cause and effect become visible only in hindsight. A chart can still schedule the next experiment and its review.

How do leaders build situational awareness?

Leaders build situational awareness by discussing their situation together, checking their account against what happens and repeating the discussion as conditions change. Each leader works from a habitual frame, such as engineering, people, power or meaning. Hearing colleagues who work from other frames shows each leader forces that no single frame brings into view.

How does the Cynefin framework help leaders choose a method?

The Cynefin framework sorts situations by how well cause and effect can be known. In simple and complicated situations they can be known in advance, so established practice, expert analysis and plans work. In complex situations they become visible only in hindsight, so leaders set boundaries, run small experiments and invest in what shows promise. In a chaotic situation, a leader first acts to stabilize things.

References (13)

This essay is developed from William Haas Evans’s manuscript Designing Resilience: The Strategy, Structure, and Spirit of Enterprise Agility.

  • Henry L. Gantt, Organizing for Work, Harcourt, Brace and Howe, 1919. Gantt’s own published account of his progress charts, which compared promises with performance, and of their use in wartime munitions production. https://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/001429896
  • Wallace Clark, The Gantt Chart: A Working Tool of Management, The Ronald Press Company, 1922. A book that helped spread the chart’s use. Wren (2015) traces the later consulting work in Europe that carried it further. https://archive.org/details/cu31924004570853
  • Daniel A. Wren, “Implementing the Gantt chart in Europe and Britain: the contributions of Wallace Clark,” Journal of Management History 21, no. 3 (2015), pages 309 to 327. https://doi.org/10.1108/JMH-09-2014-0163
  • Diana White and Joyce Fortune, “Current practice in project management: an empirical study,” International Journal of Project Management 20, no. 1 (2002), pages 1 to 11. The published title separates its two parts with a dash, changed here to a colon. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0263-7863(00)00029-6
  • David Snowden, “The Social Ecology of Knowledge Management,” in Charles Despres and Daniele Chauvel, editors, Knowledge Horizons: The Present and the Promise of Knowledge Management, Butterworth-Heinemann, 2000. The first use of the name Cynefin, according to David Snowden, “The evolution of Cynefin over a decade,” Cognitive Edge blog, 2010. https://thecynefin.co/the-evolution-of-cynefin-over-a-decade/
  • David J. Snowden, “Complex Acts of Knowing: Paradox and Descriptive Self-Awareness,” Journal of Knowledge Management 6, no. 2 (2002), pages 100 to 111. An early published account of the Cynefin framework, with five domains. https://doi.org/10.1108/13673270210424639
  • Cynthia F. Kurtz and David J. Snowden, “The new dynamics of strategy: Sense-making in a complex and complicated world,” IBM Systems Journal 42, no. 3 (2003), pages 462 to 483. A later form of the Cynefin framework, with different domain names.
  • David J. Snowden and Mary E. Boone, “A Leader’s Framework for Decision Making,” Harvard Business Review, November 2007, pages 68 to 76. The source of the Cynefin domain names used here: simple, complicated, complex, chaotic and disorder. https://hbr.org/2007/11/a-leaders-framework-for-decision-making
  • Lee G. Bolman and Terrence E. Deal, Modern Approaches to Understanding and Managing Organizations, Jossey-Bass, 1984. The first published form of the structural, human resource, political and symbolic approaches.
  • Lee G. Bolman and Terrence E. Deal, Reframing Organizations: Artistry, Choice, and Leadership, 6th edition, Jossey-Bass, 2017. The four frames as used here: the engineering, people, power and meaning frames correspond to their structural, human resource, political and symbolic frames. The machine, the jungle and the theater are their images for the engineering, power and meaning frames.
  • Karl E. Weick, Sensemaking in Organizations, Sage, 1995.
  • Karl E. Weick, Kathleen M. Sutcliffe and David Obstfeld, “Organizing and the Process of Sensemaking,” Organization Science 16, no. 4 (2005), pages 409 to 421. https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.1050.0133
  • Gary Klein, Brian Moon and Robert R. Hoffman, “Making Sense of Sensemaking 1: Alternative Perspectives,” IEEE Intelligent Systems 21, no. 4 (2006), pages 70 to 73. https://doi.org/10.1109/MIS.2006.75

William Haas Evans

Founder and chief strategy officer of Fugue Strategy Advisors. He works with leadership teams on strategy design, strategic foresight and organization design. More about William

Read next

Request a briefing

What is standing between your team and its goals this year?

Tell us in a 30-minute briefing, and we'll help you decide where to start.

Request a briefing