The Rituals Leaders Keep is an essay on organizational culture change for leadership teams whose transformation has redrawn the org chart while daily behavior has stayed the same. It shows how the rituals, symbols and decision rights leaders redesign teach an organization what matters, and why a redrawn org chart leaves behavior unchanged.
People learn a culture from what leaders do with their time
Your transformation redrew the org chart in a single quarter, and the way people work has barely changed. The meetings run as they did before. Bad news still reaches the top late and polished. We have found that organizational culture changes when leaders change what daily work teaches people to assume: which effort is rewarded and which is ignored, who may decide, and what people are allowed to notice. People learn those assumptions from how they convene, how often and for what purpose, from the written and unwritten rules of each gathering, and from the distance between what leaders announce and what they do. A new chart leaves the gatherings, the rules and the incentives as they were.
A culture is the set of meanings people build together from what they see, and the shared beliefs those meanings settle into over time. The anthropologist Clifford Geertz, crediting the idea to Max Weber, wrote that "man is an animal suspended in webs of significance he himself has spun," and took culture to be those webs. The organizational psychologist Edgar Schein traced where the webs come from: a group spins them while it learns to adapt to the world outside and to work together inside, and it teaches whatever works to newcomers as the correct way to perceive, think and feel. From then on, those beliefs decide what people notice, what they focus on and what they do about it. Leaders supply much of the material: which meetings the senior team never misses, which questions get asked there and how a leader responds when a project slips. Among the main ways leaders embed a culture, Schein listed what leaders regularly pay attention to and how they react when something goes wrong.
Some of what leaders repeat is routine, and some is ritual. A routine repeats for dependable execution, as an expense report does. A ritual repeats too, and it also says who belongs, whose knowledge counts and what the group values. In our experience, most organizations run rituals they have never named, and those rituals go on teaching the old lessons until leaders redesign them.
Unspoken assumptions and old habits outlast a new org chart
Culture sits at three levels in Schein's model: what anyone can see, such as the office and the way a meeting opens; what the organization says about itself; and, underneath, assumptions people stopped questioning long ago. Who may make which call? Is a missed date a fact to report or a failure to hide? The answers guide what people do every day.
In our experience, those unspoken assumptions come mostly from the way decisions, information, power and rewards are arranged. Culture, as the management scholar Ralph Stacey described it, emerges from everyday conversations and from who has power over whom. Much of that arrangement is tacit: people learn how work really gets done, and who owes whom a favor, long before anyone writes it down. An org chart records who reports to whom. Decision rights record who may decide and who must be consulted. Incentives record which behavior is amplified and which is left to fade.
A new chart also leaves people's trained instincts in place, and in our view those instincts explain why the old behavior outlasts the chart. Long experience in one social setting, as the sociologist Pierre Bourdieu argued, leaves people with lasting habits of perception and response, which he called habitus. People formed in the same setting respond alike without consulting one another, so the old organization keeps coordinating itself under the new chart. A manager who learned that flagging a project as off track invites interrogation tends to report it on track under any chart.
A canceled meeting or a surrendered privilege can change what people learn
The meetings a leader runs are the part of daily experience that leader can change directly. With our coaching, a technology executive in a large enterprise started a culture change by canceling one meeting. In our view, that monthly meeting, where his direct reports came to his office and presented slide decks, taught them that the job was to appear in control.
In its place he began a monthly walk to each of the major groups that reported to him. He stood at each group's project boards and asked three questions: "What's going on?", "What do you hope to learn from this?" and "How can I help?" The second question turned the talk toward learning, and the third put the executive in service of the team. The questions also changed what people watched for. A review that asks only whether a date will be met teaches people to watch dates, and one that asks what a team has learned teaches them to watch for evidence. Attention can be trained on purpose. For about two years I photographed one Copperplate Gothic storefront sign each day in lower Manhattan, and that daily practice let me see the neighborhood begin to change when Papyrus signs started replacing them.
In our experience, symbols teach most at a threshold, the point where a group leaves one condition for another. In our view, each person in an organization meets a smaller version of the threshold Joseph Campbell described for the hero, who has outgrown a familiar horizon and whose old ideas no longer fit. In another organization, the senior leaders gave up their reserved parking spaces, and employees took the change as a sign that the hardship would be shared.
A ritual is worth keeping when something changes after it
The walks justify the executive's time only if something he hears at a project board leads to a different decision or a new way of working. When nothing changes, people learn that the walk is theater. A symbol faces the same test, because leaders who give up a visible privilege and keep the advantage behind it teach cynicism.
Rituals also distribute power. Whoever designs one decides who speaks, which questions are welcome and when a discussion is finished. A ritual that is compulsory, that asks people to display feelings on cue or that cannot change anything can become a way of enforcing conformity. A good ritual states its purpose, protects the person who disagrees and lets the people whose work it governs decide how to redesign it. In our experience, the protection of dissent decides whether bad news reaches the top early.
A team's own rituals can also shift decision rights into the team. In teams we have coached, checks once owned by a separate function, such as quality assurance, were written into the exit criteria on the team's board as one question: what must be true before this work goes to the next step? A specialist from that function joined the team's design reviews to advise, and the team decided inside its own process. The team no longer waited on another function before its work could advance.
Every leader already runs rituals, so every leader is already teaching the culture. Start with the meeting where bad news usually arrives, since that meeting decides how early you hear about risk. Redesign it so the person who raises a risk is protected, and watch whether the next risk reaches you sooner.
To see how leadership teams put these ideas to work, explore the talk Dispositioning Advantage: Designing Strategy Around Culture, Context and Capability, or request a briefing.
Questions leaders ask about changing culture
How do you change organizational culture?
We have found that culture changes when leaders change what daily work teaches people to assume: which effort is rewarded, who may decide and what people are allowed to notice. People learn those assumptions from how they convene, from the written and unwritten rules of each gathering and from incentives. Start with the meeting where bad news usually arrives, since it decides how early leaders hear of risk.
Why doesn't a reorganization change culture?
A reorganization redraws reporting lines and leaves in place the rituals, decision rights and habits that teach people how to act. In our view, people's trained instincts explain why old behavior outlasts the new structure. A manager who learned that flagging a slipping project invites interrogation tends to call that project on track under any org chart.
What makes a workplace ritual worth keeping?
A ritual is worth keeping when something changes after it. A leader's walk to project boards earns its time when a comment heard there leads to a different decision or way of working. If nothing follows, people learn the walk is theater. A good ritual states its purpose, protects dissent and lets those whose work it governs redesign it.
References (6)
- Clifford Geertz, "Thick Description: Toward an Interpretive Theory of Culture," in The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays, Basic Books, 1973, page 5 (culture as "webs of significance," an idea Geertz credits to Max Weber).
- Edgar H. Schein with Peter Schein, Organizational Culture and Leadership, 5th edition, Wiley, 2017, chapter 2, "The Structure of Culture" (the three levels of culture), chapter 9, "How External Adaptation and Internal Integration Become Culture" (culture as what a group has learned in solving its problems of external adaptation and internal integration), and chapter 10, "How Leaders Embed and Transmit Culture" (what leaders regularly pay attention to, measure and control, and how they react to critical incidents). https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/organizational-culture-and/9781119212041/
- Edgar H. Schein, "Coming to a New Awareness of Organizational Culture," Sloan Management Review 25, no. 2 (Winter 1984), beginning page 3 (assumptions that have worked well enough to be taught to new members as "the correct way to perceive, think, and feel"). https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/coming-to-a-new-awareness-of-organizational-culture
- Pierre Bourdieu, Outline of a Theory of Practice, translated by Richard Nice, Cambridge University Press, 1977, chapter 2, pages 72 to 95 (habitus as durable dispositions, and practices orchestrated without a conductor).
- Joseph Campbell, The Hero with a Thousand Faces, Pantheon Books, 1949, page 51 (the hero who has outgrown the familiar horizon, at the threshold of a passage).
- Ralph D. Stacey, Complexity and Organizational Reality: Uncertainty and the Need to Rethink Management after the Collapse of Investment Capitalism, 2nd edition, Routledge, 2010 (organizations as patterns of local interaction and power relations). https://www.routledge.com/Complexity-and-Organizational-Reality-Uncertainty-and-the-Need-to-Rethink/Stacey/p/book/9780415556477

