A Purpose That Says No is an essay on organizational purpose for executive and leadership teams whose mission statement sounds right and changes nothing. It shows how a purpose becomes a working constraint on the choices people make every week, above all the choice to decline.
An organizational purpose earns its place in the decisions it changes
Many leadership teams have a mission or purpose statement that everyone endorses and nobody uses to decide anything. The statement appears on the website and in the annual report, and the budget gets settled on other grounds. In our experience, a purpose too vague to use leaves people with nothing to choose by, so each hard choice falls back on habit. An organizational purpose is worth writing down when it changes those choices, above all the choice to decline work that looks good.
A clear purpose works as a limit that makes choosing easier. It narrows the options people consider, which lets them choose well and quickly. The choices a purpose governs are the hard ones: which acquisitions to make, which customer segments to serve, which regions to invest in, and which skills leaders need to develop in their people.
Because a purpose names the organization's reason to exist, it points a direction without fixing the route. People still have to work out the route. They can work it out because they know what the route is for.
Purpose pays when people can see how to use it
Profit follows from good work and gives no guidance on which work to do. For a generation, many large companies said their purpose was to maximize shareholder value. That framing told employees and investors how performance would be judged. It said little about which customers to serve or which work to stop.
In our judgment, a longer list of groups to serve improves a statement of values and still does not tell anyone which project to stop. In August 2019, 181 chief executives of large companies set the shareholder-value framing aside in public. Their association, the Business Roundtable, had said in its statements since 1997 that corporations exist principally to serve shareholders. The new statement of corporate purpose committed their firms to customers, employees, suppliers, communities and shareholders.
Our working judgment is that a purpose pays when the people making everyday decisions can see how to use it. About 500,000 survey responses from workers at U.S. companies fit that judgment. Firms whose people reported both a strong purpose and clear direction from management went on to show higher accounting and stock market performance. Purpose on its own showed no such relation, and the performance link came from the answers of middle managers and professional staff.
A focused purpose can end good work an organization already funds
A broad mission spreads an organization thin, because almost any new initiative can claim to serve it. Each initiative looks reasonable alone, and together they leave too little capacity to finish what matters, a pattern often called mission creep. In our experience, mission creep produces long lead times, failed projects, duplicated work, wasted resources and disengaged employees, and these symptoms appear well before anyone names their cause.
A narrower purpose can cost an organization work it values, and Patagonia gave a public example. In December 2018 the company rewrote its mission as "Patagonia is in business to save our home planet." Its founder explained what the wording meant for the company's roughly 900 grants a year. One recipient was a group that repaired people's bicycles, and that group would get no more money. The company's stated reason was that it had been funding too many groups that treated symptoms, and the new purpose directed its money to root causes and solutions.
A specific purpose tells people what to refuse, even when refusing costs something
A purpose written specifically enough tells people what work to do. Hull House, the settlement house that Jane Addams and Ellen Gates Starr opened in Chicago in 1889, named three aims in its charter: "To provide a center for a higher civic and social life; to institute and maintain educational and philanthropic enterprises, and to investigate and improve the conditions in the industrial districts of Chicago." Its residents acted on all three: they lived in the neighborhood, mapped its nationalities and wages, and pressed for the 1893 Illinois law that set fourteen as the minimum age for factory work.
That purpose also told Hull House what to refuse. Some years after the house opened, a trustee arrived with good news. A friend of his was ready to give twenty thousand dollars to build the Jane Club a clubhouse. The Jane Club was the cooperative boarding club that young working women had started near Hull House in 1891. Then the residents heard the donor's name. He was "notorious for underpaying the girls in his establishment." The residents judged that a clubhouse for working women could not be paid for with money made by underpaying working women, and they declined at once. In our judgment, that refusal applied the charter's third aim, to improve conditions in Chicago's industrial districts.
Declining had two costs. The Jane Club went without the clubhouse its members had sought. Hull House also could not announce the refusal, because a representative of the house had asked for the gift. Eventually a longtime friend of the house built the club its new home.
The test of a purpose is the last project it stopped
The question "Does this serve our purpose?" belongs in portfolio reviews, operating reviews and board meetings, where the next investment, the next hire and the next partnership get decided. People at every level should hear leaders ask it, and should see what leaders do with the answer, because people learn to use a purpose by watching it decide real cases.
Leaders can check their own purpose with one question. Can you name a project or initiative you said no to because it did not serve your purpose? If nobody can, the purpose is decoration. If the answers come quickly, and some of them were good, popular or already funded, the purpose is doing its work.
To see how leadership teams put these ideas to work, explore the talk Dispositioning Advantage: Designing Strategy Around Culture, Context and Capability, or request a briefing.
Questions leaders ask about organizational purpose
What makes an organizational purpose useful?
An organizational purpose is useful when it changes the choices people make, above all the choice to decline work that looks good. A clear purpose works as a limit that makes choosing easier, because it narrows the options people consider. People can then decide well and quickly on hard questions, such as acquisitions, customer segments and regional investment.
Why does a mission statement often change nothing?
In our experience, a mission statement changes nothing when it is too vague to use, so each hard choice falls back on habit. The statement appears on the website and in the annual report, and the budget gets settled on other grounds. A broad mission also spreads an organization thin, because almost any new initiative can claim to serve it.
How can you tell whether your organizational purpose is working?
A purpose is working when people can name a project the organization turned down because the project did not serve that purpose. If nobody can name one, the statement is decoration. If answers come quickly, and some of the declined projects were good, popular or already funded, the purpose is doing its job.
References (7)
- Jane Addams, Twenty Years at Hull-House, with Autobiographical Notes, Macmillan, 1910, chapter 5, "First Days at Hull-House" (charter wording); chapter 7, "Some Early Undertakings at Hull-House" (the Jane Club and the declined gift); chapter 10, "Pioneer Labor Legislation in Illinois" (the first factory law). https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/1325
- Jeff Beer, "Exclusive: Patagonia Is in Business to Save Our Home Planet", Fast Company, 13 December 2018. https://www.fastcompany.com/90280950/exclusive-patagonia-is-in-business-to-save-our-home-planet
- Business Roundtable, "Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation", 19 August 2019. https://www.businessroundtable.org/business-roundtable-redefines-the-purpose-of-a-corporation-to-promote-an-economy-that-serves-all-americans. Summarized in Cydney S. Posner, "So Long to Shareholder Primacy", Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, 22 August 2019. https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2019/08/22/so-long-to-shareholder-primacy/
- Peter F. Drucker, Managing the Non-Profit Organization: Principles and Practices, HarperCollins, 1990, chapter 1, on right action as the test of a mission.
- Claudine Gartenberg, Andrea Prat and George Serafeim, "Corporate Purpose and Financial Performance", Organization Science 30, no. 1 (2019): 1 to 18. https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2018.1230
- Alicia Juarrero, Dynamics in Action: Intentional Behavior as a Complex System, MIT Press, 1999, on enabling constraints, the idea that a limit can make action possible.
- Robert A. Woods and Albert J. Kennedy, Handbook of Settlements, Russell Sage Foundation, 1911, entry for Hull House (incorporation in 1894). https://socialwelfare.library.vcu.edu/settlement-houses/hull-house-circ-1910/

